“When you think you’ve got hold of it all. You haven’t got a hold at all“
Depeche Mode, Get the Balance Right
Last week, we discussed the recent market reaction to the stronger-than-expected payroll and inflation data for January - questioning the correlation of the data to several other high frequency data releases that paint a far less rosy picture of US economic momentum and consumer activity. We also discussed the details of the minutes from the Jan 31st/Feb 1st FOMC policy meeting and highlighted the fact that there was a clear discussion of the interaction of the two factors - inflation and growth. Indeed, on growth the FOMC minutes were clear that "...cumulative policy firming to date had reduced demand in the most interest-rate-sensitive sectors of the economy, particularly housing”. Furthermore, some participants "noted that the probability of the economy entering a recession in 2023 remained elevated." And the overall Fed assessment of the balance of risks to growth remained to the downside.
This week, there have been a number of data prints that have added to the debate between the dominant dynamic- growth or inflation - and the implications for the monetary policy evolution as the year progresses. Indeed, commentary from Cleveland Federal Reserve President , that while the current cost of undershooting on rates outweigh the costs of doing too much, as inflation falls she expects the balance of risks to shift.
From our perspective this is important, as we remain of the view that the data suggesting a renewed acceleration in consumer activity are anomalous and thus that the current trajectory, and indeed the balance of risks remain skewed to the downside for growth. Thus, our view is that the ‘true picture’ warrants Cleveland Feds President ‘shift’.
This week, there have been some new developments that have contributed to the debate. US consumer confidence fell sharply, data on national house prices showed that prices fell by an annualised 5.4% in the last six months of 2022 and, Chicago Fed and Richmond Fed activity indices both showed further declines into historically very weak territory. Broad leading indicators continue to show underlying economic weakness.
At the same time that the broad data paint a less than convincing picture of underlying US growth, the rate repricing continues. Tightening of financial conditions continues. Indeed, while last week we discussed the concept that the markets had been encouraged to price higher terminal rates by the better-than-expected data, inference from Fed speakers over recent weeks is that forecasts are unlikely to rise beyond (or even equivalent) current market curve pricing. (Bullard indicated his forecast of around 5.375% and Bostic 5.125% - against a current market implied Fed Funds terminal rate of 5.45%).
From a USD perspective the argument is even more complex. Higher than expected inflation prints in Spain, France and Germany this week have driven renewed hawkishness in European curves with markets pricing an ECB terminal rate above 4.00%. Indeed, markets are pricing a further 148bps of ECB tightening by the Autumn relative to 86bps in the US. This divergence is keeping yields differentials (at the 2 year and 10 year yield levels) narrowing in favour of the EUR. Furthermore, as long as European rate expectations continue to be supported by sufficient growth expectations the USD can remain in the trough of the USD smile. Our structural views on the capital flow, valuation and cyclical drivers of a higher EURUSD remain.
Technically, the USD has found some significant resistance levels at 1.05 (EURUSD), 7.00 (USDCNY), 138.00 (USDJPY), and even 18.50 (USDZAR) over recent sessions. Next week’s data on US employment (ADP, JOLTS and Payrolls) is likely very significant in this regard. We remain of the view that next week’s data is vulnerable to an unwinding of the seasonal adjustment, weather, and strike distortions of the January data. If we are correct - so is the recent sharp repricing of US rates and strengthening of the USD. Data next week (and the CPI print the subsequent week) are critical to the near-term evolution of the Fed reaction function (to the balance of known risks) and thus will be a huge focus for financial markets.
Ahead of the US employment data and the Fed response, the RBA has some complicated decisions of their own. Coming into 2023, market expectations were forming a consensus that the RBA was at, or at least very near, the terminal rate in the current hiking cycle. However, in the runup to the February meeting there was an unexpected spike in inflation that caused analysts and the RBA to respond with a further 25bp hike and more hawkish projections. Furthermore, following the rate hike the RBA acknowledged two consecutively weak employment reports and that further signs of labour market weakness (to remove year end / seasonal adjustment doubt) would have more dovish monetary connotations. This week the most recent Australian CPI print fell sharply. The RBA this week - ahead of an updated labour market report - thus face a complicated balance. I would expect a slightly more cautious narrative to emerge - a narrative, and a data path that may also hold lessons for other global central banks at the current juncture.
Ultimately, we continue to believe that the balance of risks is more skewed towards disinflation than inflation and growth weakness than excess demand in 2023. While the likely distortions over the year end (and as a function of covid disruptions to the historic comparisons) make the policymakers job more complex, to paraphrase Depeche Mode the Fed and other global central banks increasingly need to “get the balance right” - especially as growth and inflation slow.
Have you listened to Neil's podcast series?
Subscribe to our insights
If you are interested in our content, please sign up below and we will deliver Eurizon SLJ insights right to your inbox.
I consent to my data being collected and stored for the purposes of providing me information regarding my enquiry and related services. If you have any questions about your data please contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org
This communication is issued by Eurizon SLJ Capital Limited (“ESLJ”), a private limited company registered in England (company number: 09775525) having its registered office at 90 Queen Street, London EC4N 1SA, United Kingdom. ESLJ is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN: 736926). This communication is treated as a marketing communication intended for professional investors only and is provided only for information purposes. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal and regulatory requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and is not subject to any prohibition on dealing ahead of the dissemination of investment research. It does not constitute research on investment matters and should not be construed as containing any recommendation, advice or suggestion, implicit or explicit, with respect to any investment strategy or financial instruments, or the issuers of any financial instruments, or a solicitation, offer or financial promotion relating to any securities or investments. ESLJ and its affiliates do not assume any liability whatsoever for the contents of this communication, save to the extent agreed in any written contract entered into between ESLJ and the recipient, and do not make any representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of any information contained in this communication. Views are accurate as at the time of publication. Opinions expressed by individuals are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of ESLJ or any of its affiliates. The value of any investment may change and an investor may not get back the original amount invested. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. This communication may not be reproduced, redistributed or copied in whole or in part for any purpose. It may not be distributed in any jurisdiction where its distribution may be restricted by law and persons into whose possession this communication comes should inform themselves about, and observe, any such restrictions.